Chicken Shawarma with Garlic Sauce

My strongest, unshakeable culinary conviction — besides the holiness of good butter and the emotional support Trader Joe’s gives me on Tuesdays — is that chicken shawarma with garlic sauce should be its own national holiday. Also: forks are culprits. Two-word truth.

The Thanksgiving that ended in a smoke alarm symphony

I once tried to impress my extended family with "authentic vibes" and a rotisserie-style chicken shawarma on Thanksgiving, because why not replace turkey with something that smells like heaven and regret? Spoiler: I misread "medium-high" as "volcanic," and there was a lot of smoke, my aunt hugged a fire extinguisher like a security blanket, and we ended up ordering pizza from the place that always runs out of rosemary (history repeating — sigh).

My past cooking disasters deserve their own reality TV show — lemon bars of 2019, the mashed-potato lava incident of 2020 — but the shawarma debacle taught me the single most valuable lesson: marinade like you mean it, and control your heat like it’s your last fragile relationship. Also, always keep napkins within arm’s reach. Emotional and practical.

ANYWAY — back to the actual life-saving recipe

Before I spiral into another flashback about crinkly napkins and Aunt Susan’s judgmental face (love you, Susan), let’s make something that doesn’t set off the sprinkler system. This version is forgiving, bright, and smells like warm spices and second chances.

I will say: if you want that buttery, cozy roastiness, try crisping edges on a hot pan rather than torching things in a misguided moment. Also, sometimes I borrow techniques from recipes that look intimidating and pretend they’re mine — chefs are therapists, right? For more stuffed-chicken inspiration (because I am that chaotic), check out this cheesy garlic butter mushroom stuffed chicken for weeknight heroics.

The shopping list (no drama, just ingredients — mostly)

• Boneless chicken thighs or breasts (thighs if you like drama, breasts if you’re trying to be trusted)
• Plain yogurt
• Olive oil
• Garlic cloves (yes, more than you think)
• Lemon juice
• Ground cumin
• Paprika (smoked if you’re feeling fancy)
• Ground cinnamon (tiny pinch; yes, really)
• Salt
• Black pepper
• Pita bread
• Fresh vegetables: lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers
• Garlic sauce (toum or homemade — see technique)

Mini-rants: Trader Joe’s has killer yogurt and steals on spices, Aldi has my back when my wallet weeps, and the difference between "cheap" and "nice" olive oil is real but don’t cry over it. If you want holiday-level impressiveness on a Tuesday, splurge on good garlic and fresh pita. Also, if you like stuffing things (guilty), consider this cranberry-spinach stuffed chicken because yes, I put stuffing on everything in December.

Cooking Unit Converter: because conversions make me slightly less anxious

If you hate guessing tablespoons vs. grams (me), drop your measurements here and pretend adulthood is organized.

Technique breakdown: how to not ruin everything (a rambly love letter to cooking)

I will rant: marinating is where feelings become flavor. Treat the chicken like a diary — let it soak up your confessions (aka yogurt, lemon, garlic, spices). Heat control is the difference between "golden" and "call the neighbors."

Here’s what I learned the hard way: don’t crowd the pan; give the chicken room to crisp. Resting the cooked meat is not optional; it’s the culinary equivalent of therapy. And if the garlic sauce screams for more lemon, listen to it. Senses are not liars — smell it, taste it, feel the tension dissolve.

Use also this list:

1. In a bowl, combine yogurt, olive oil, minced garlic, lemon juice, cumin, paprika, cinnamon, salt, and pepper.
2. Add the chicken to the marinade and let it sit for at least 1 hour, or overnight for best results.
3. Preheat your grill or stovetop pan over medium-high heat.
4. Remove the chicken from the marinade and grill for about 6-7 minutes on each side, until cooked through and juices run clear.
5. Once cooked, let the chicken rest for a few minutes before slicing.
6. Serve in pita bread with fresh vegetables and drizzle with garlic sauce. Enjoy!

If you crave extra char, steal a trick from a totally different school of cooking — seriously, I learned some glorious charring techniques from an unexpected corner: perfect char siu chicken tips. Not the same, but the sear wisdom translates.

Why this matters to me (yes, emotionally)

Cooking is my time machine. A spoonful of lemon takes me back to a cramped kitchen where my mom hummed and burned the edges of flatbread while the radio played standards. Food is tradition, identity, and that small miracle where heat and patience become comfort. This recipe is a patchwork of those memories: spicy warmth, sticky garlic sauce, and the stubborn joy of feeding people.

Tiny anecdote — the pita that saved Thanksgiving

Once, after the smoke alarm incident, I wrapped leftover shawarma in pita and handed it to Aunt Susan. She took one bite, then one more, and declared it "actually edible." We never spoke about the fire again. Small victories.

Frequently Asked Questions:

Okay, I’ll stop now (for real) — just make this, invite someone over, and let the garlic sauce do the talking. If Aunt Susan shows up, bring a second batch. Your future self will thank you.

Daily Calorie Needs Calculator: figure out if this counts as a main or an indulgence

Plug in your details to see how this meal fits into your day.